Skip to content
Simple Insight offers clear, practical perspectives on life…

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Dynamic Portrait of Magdalene.

One woman throws her head back. Lids sealed, lips sealed, yet she is awake and aware. With warm cheeks and vermilion lips, her flowing golden hair is illuminated by the flare from a nearby candle, casting a luminous glow in an otherwise shadowy chamber. She wears includes a lace-trimmed chemise—falling down one arm to reveal porcelain skin—to a rich ochre and amethyst garment. Seemingly by herself, unaware of any viewer, existing in a state of sublime freedom.

An Important Institutional First

This subject is Mary Magdalene experiencing rapture, painted in the 1620s by the Italian Baroque artist Gentileschi. Freshly purchased by the prestigious institution in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on exhibition from late February. It represents the institution’s first purchase of a work by Gentileschi, and curator a leading scholar has observed that it portrays the religious figure as “free from remorse and pain”. This is an important distinction, for centuries, Magdalene’s image has been shaped not just by biblical text but fabulated and conflated by powerful male figures.

“The most flexible character in sacred iconography,” as one expert observed.

Look at portrayals of her and you encounter a thinker, orator, follower, and witness; crying at the foot of the crucifix, anointing Jesus’s feet, or looking toward the sky—frequently repenting with pearl-like tears and, too often, revealing her chest. At times recognized by a ointment vessel or a scarlet cloak—unlike the Madonna’s azure—she is widely regarded today as a romantic companion of Jesus, even though no biblical passage labeling her as such.

The Layers of Interpretation

“The truth is, we cannot be certain who she was,” said the expert. “So all these layers of meaning have fallen upon her. The transformations she undergoes, not just visually but narratively, in worship, theologically, are as much related to societal views and religious changes as they are to belief.” What then do we know?

She is mentioned in the New Testament twelve times. Initially, she has evil spirits expelled from her; subsequently, she is seen at the crucifixion and is the first person to experience his rising. It is she who proclaims the “good news”. Her sexual and immoral legacy can largely be traced to a homily delivered in the 500s by Pope Gregory the Great, who combined her with another Mary and an unnamed sinner who bathed Christ’s feet with her tears.

In lumping them together, Pope Gregory in essence “invented” the penitent fallen woman—a myth further expanded by subsequent theologians and medieval texts. Painters and sculptors took note, and in a predominantly non-reading but visually literate world, this proved influential. The “seven demons” became the “seven deadly sins”, cementing her dominant story as one of moral lapse and later redemption—solidified in paintings and sculptures that continue to influence beliefs today.

A Legacy of Suffering and Sexualization

From the sculptor’s gaunt, skeletal Magdalene clasping her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s 1606 portrayal of her drained of color and near death—not to mention yet another artist’s partially clothed, rapturous saint supported by angels. Mary Magdalene has frequently been denigrated sexually. Albrecht Dürer’s print presented her coyly, with cascading hair draping her unclothed body, while another’s interpretation gazes heavenward, with tearful eyes and strategically placed hands exposing her form.

It seems, anguish and sexualization were the dominant extremes in her representation: she could serve as a warning against sin, be the exemplar for repentance, while providing artists a pretext to depict the female form masked as piety. This “fallen woman redeemed” trope endured for hundreds of years—so profoundly that institutions called “Magdalene laundries” subjected women into exploitative labor, a practice that astonishingly ended just thirty years ago.

A Radical Reimagining

But what if there was another side to her narrative? What if her journey could be one of spiritual awakening and metamorphosis, where she was pictured as vibrant, joy, and transcendence? Essentially, what if we viewed her via the eyes of a woman?

This is what Gentileschi achieves. This Magdalene is not posing for the viewer; she is not weeping, not penitent, without shame, not objectified, and not dictating a moral lesson. Rather, she sports flushed cheeks and is, according to notes, “passionately alive … in the grip of divine joy”. One curator stated that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an electrifying vitality”.

“Yes, it’s an rapture painting, but it’s not her moment of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … described at times as if it’s the finest physical experience … the most profound ecstasy she could ever have. It’s beautiful, it’s physical, it’s sensual, it’s transcendent. You are lifted beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Frequently, when women portray scriptural or mythological women, they show them not as submissive, guilty, ashamed, or inferior, but as active, multifaceted, and with wills of their own: “Females with a capital ‘W’”.

A Greater Shift Towards Equality

Therefore, while this new Gentileschi might finally be correcting a gender imbalance at the institution, its significance extends further. It alters not just how we view biblical and mythological women, but also the female experience at large.

This view is one the Catholic church eventually acknowledged. In the late 1960s, it officially affirmed her official definition as a devoted disciple rather than a penitent sinner. More recently 2016, the pontiff elevated her status to “apostle to the apostles”, marking a day in July as her feast day. It seems that, as establishments change, viewpoints are shifting. This acquisition—of a woman free from a male perspective, existing for her own sake, without anguish and not exploited—is part of a larger movement towards equality.

AD
The writer

Alvin Durham

James Whitaker is a writer and thinker who explores the beauty of simplicity in everyday life.

Simple Insight

Type to search articles.